← VBar NEO/EVO VLink

V8 Main Rotor Gain Questions translated

VBar › VBar NEO/EVO VLink · Started by jgmeiner on 10 February 2026 08:5410.02.2026 08:54
jgmeiner 10 February 2026 08:5410.02.2026 08:54
Good morning team,

I have two questions about the main rotor gain in V8.2:
1. Why is the gain adjustable in multiples of 4? I find this somewhat unintuitive from a UI perspective.
2. The gain setting likely incorporates the prop and distortion components. How does the integral component, which I can adjust separately, fit into this? Is it an absolute value, or is it affected by the gain?

Thanks,
Johannes
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 10 February 2026 10:2610.02.2026 10:26
Hi Johannes,

The 'problem' is that it's all old news. Virtually all parameters are defined as 7-bit values, 0...127.
If more are needed, there's a trick, and then the stored values are simply multiplied.
With a factor of 4 we get 480, that's enough for now :-)

The resolution suffers as a result... but that doesn't really matter.

The gain, or overall sensitivity, or overall amplification of the control system is essentially a factor for the individual control loop components.
P – Proportional share
I – Integrator – Heading-Hold Share
D – Differential component

Put simply, if you turned the overall sensitivity down to zero, the control would become increasingly lax (until 0, off); if you pushed it to the maximum, it would become so sharp that the entire system would eventually start to oscillate.

The values you load with a setup are based on good experience. That's what VBar is all about: create a basic setup, go flying, and have fun.
If you have any questions, look elsewhere or feel free to ask here, but please be specific: Heli is doing this or that, what can I do to make it do something else?

Anyone who wants to study control engineering is welcome to do so, but it's not a requirement for entry :-)

Grüßle

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.



1 mal bearbeitet. Zuletzt am 10.02.2026 10:27 von Eddi E. aus G..
machine-translated from German · Show original
jgmeiner 10 February 2026 11:0910.02.2026 11:09
Hi Eddie, thanks, I have two Specter V2s, and both show the following image with the V8 as described by colleague SME (wobbling with small nick inputs).
https://youtube.com/shorts/R2GbhpLJwLY?si=u6XPpnhI2fA0CkCb

You can clearly see that it only wobbles with slight pitch inputs, but locks into place very nicely with hard stops. Swashplate frequency 166Hz, gain 84, I-gain 70. If I lower the I-gain to 35, it's smooth. I haven't noticed any other disadvantages, but I haven't been able to test it extensively yet. For example, if I compare this to my TDSF, where I fly with around 190 gain and the I-gain is still at 70...
And in the neighboring thread (https://www.vstabi.info/forum/read.php?64,209435) Uli described:

"In the current V8 settings, we do set I somewhat higher in the default setting because it usually improves flight and especially hovering behavior. However, a high I setting is only possible if a high base gain is also available."

Perhaps 70 I-Gain is simply too high with a maximum gain of 84? Especially in the cold, where the damping is significantly harsher...

That's why I'm trying to understand how gain and I-gain are related on the V8. I don't actually want to study control engineering; I have complete faith in you guys. I just want to get my helicopters dialed in properly...

Thanks,
Johannes
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 10 February 2026 11:5210.02.2026 11:52
Hi,

Well, if it works well at 80 with 35 I, then that's probably what best suits the helicopter in question and its equipment.
The question then becomes: can the overall gain be increased even further, up to the (audible) oscillation limit?
And... does that make sense, or is it simply fine as it is?

And yes, that could also be due to the current temperatures, when everything is harder and more difficult to move.
Not the best time to fine-tune setups :-)

A different head, or different servos, or different blades, or even just a different rotational speed, and it might look completely different.
Servo position (standing/lying), mounting (damper or not), VBar bearing, overall vibration level of the mechanics (especially high-frequency from the drive) and so on and so forth... there are so many influencing factors and parameters, and the corridor where it works optimally becomes ever narrower the more power is demanded and drawn :-)

We've seen setups with total gains over 300 (where everything just fits together perfectly...) – if the system doesn't become unbalanced, you can certainly do that, and – as Uli writes – you can also increase the relative impedance (I). The relationship between I, P, and D is sometimes even more interesting than the absolute value; P attenuates I, D attenuates P, ... but that's getting too deep.

The good thing is that you can change parameters directly and compare them, or even switch between banks with otherwise identical settings during flight.

But basically, I is still what it is: Heading Hold (when left alone) and Rotation Rate Stabilization (when controlled, constant Roll or Flip Rate, for example), and regardless of the numerical value, which can vary greatly depending on the model, and depending on personal taste, it ranges from less to more to I-rocking (re-oscillation).

Grüßle

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
machine-translated from German · Show original
jgmeiner 10 February 2026 14:4610.02.2026 14:46
Okay, thanks for your explanation.
Both Specters work with these settings for me. However, they are equipped with different servos, and this is independent of the blades.
Yes, the great thing about Vstabi is that you can just try things out, even without landing!
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 10 February 2026 15:4210.02.2026 15:42
Hey,

Yes... then it's probably what's best suited to the Specter's rotor head.

I'd be curious to know what settings other pilots have used, or were able to use, on their Specters, which components they have, which helicopter generation, and so on... it's getting quite extensive again :-)

Is the result then a spectrogram?
Are specialists needed for this?
Spectacular :-)

AAaahhhh ... :-)

—Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
machine-translated from German · Show original
jgmeiner 11 February 2026 15:3811.02.2026 15:38
Incidentally, something else that helped with my Specters was setting the stop support to 60 (or lowering the I-component). However, such a high stop support resulted in a rather sluggish response time...
I will test again on Friday.
I also spoke with Daniel Wiedenmann, and he can't explain why my Specters are behaving this way either. He's optimized many Specters for V8 engines, and with my settings and components, they should fly perfectly. Even at -10 degrees Celsius.
All I can say is that both Specters, with different servos, are behaving this way in the cold. In the summer, when I first tested the V8 on one of the Specters, there was no wobble at all after the gain was optimized.
machine-translated from German · Show original
Eddi E. aus G. 12 February 2026 10:0712.02.2026 10:07
Good morning,

I can only say the opposite: I've experienced this with all sorts of LOGOs and my forays into Plöchinger and Vario, and on one or two scale models as well, sometimes in cold weather (understandable... they then needed a winter setup, a good cleaning, and a few drops of suitable lubricant :-) ), but also with virtually identical helicopters, especially the same blades (just new ones...), the same head, the same servos; one wobbles (constantly or when triggered), the other doesn't.

The first time it became interesting (from a support point of view) was with what we affectionately called the wobble :-) i.e. the first SABs which, as is more common here, always wobbled at normal-moderate engine speeds, but not above 2,200-2,400 rpm.

Sure, you can achieve a lot with parameters, adjust them, mask problems, but it's always stuck in my mind that a rotor head should have damping that deserves the name, and even that may need to be adjusted.
Otherwise, it looks like Formula 1 for almost the entire first year of ground effect, except they called it porpoising, where the interplay of aero and mechanics was at its limit... oh, right, that's the case with us too :-)
I think it wasn't fixed with electronic filtering and parameters, but with good old mechanical engineering.

Grüßle

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
machine-translated from German · Show original
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless