← VBar Control Classic

Elevator moves "notchy"

VBar Control › VBar Control Classic · Started by Mark Norris on 5 November 2025 22:2005.11.2025 22:20
Mark Norris 5 November 2025 22:2005.11.2025 22:20
Hello,
I have a new Vbar Control EVO setup in a new Tron 7 heli. I've only flew / hovered a few times trying to get things dialed in.

One of the first things I noticed was when adding UP or DN elevator it is very "notchy" when moving foreword and backward during hovering. I tried changing some settings but it remained. I decided to see how it behaved on the bench / no motor and the cyclic fore and aft servos were also moving a bit notchy by themselves. I moved everything around to the full extents a few times and now it moves normal & flies normal.

Very strange and I hate it when things go unsolved. Do you think its possible that there is antenna interference on the cyclic servos, the wires are pretty close at the moment. Is my setup too messy, would love to hear your thoughts.

Mark

Eddi E. aus G. 6 November 2025 09:2106.11.2025 09:21
Hi Mark,

weird indeed.

Apart from the fact (in my opinion) that the antenna layout is—let's put it euphemistically :-) —suboptimal, I doubt that the antennas interfere with the servo signals, unless they were very sensitive.
And why should it change when you move everything around, to full extent, and then stay that way?

Best antenna layout is still aft, on top of the boom, like it would be with our (or similar) antenna mounts.
The last 3+3 cm (or 1.2+1.2 in) of the antenna are where the music plays, and they should not be close to conducting materials like carbon or aluminum.

On the bench, I found it quite normal that fast HV servos with high refresh rate looked operating notchy, because the whole signal chain is so fast that it picks up even the slightest tremors. In flight, with the control loop in action, it's 'normal', then. Unless you were nervous on the sticks, of course, the servos do what you do :-) and if you shake, they (make the model) shake.

With VBar Control EVO+ you could counter that to some degree, with the control response settings for the gimbals.
There was that customer who was nervous, always, when flying at events. He said his funnels or pirouetting funnels were always looking shaky, because of his nervousness at the sticks. He then dialed down even to the Senior setting, which smoothens the stick inputs somewhat, and said he never did such good funnels :-)

—Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Mark Norris 7 November 2025 02:0207.11.2025 02:02
Getting better, appreciate all the great advise.

Mark

Eddi E. aus G. 7 November 2025 08:5007.11.2025 08:50
Hi Mark,

yes, now this looks clean :-)

One thing you might still want to do is, guide the antennas to the tips, inside a non-conducting tube, so they can no longer flap around.

Think of it like the old terrestrial antennas on radios or TVs, which had their best reception at a particular orientation.
Of course that's not possible here, and it's normally not really tragic, but since all orientation changes actually affect the radio link, you wouldn't want to add extra to the movements of the heli itself.

Just some things you learn when you look at it thoroughly :-)

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Mark Norris 8 November 2025 01:0908.11.2025 01:09
Hi Eddi, How's this. Everything working perfect at the moment.
Thanks for helping me along.

Mark

Mark Norris 9 November 2025 18:0009.11.2025 18:00
Hello,
I was flying again, and again I noticed the elevator being very notchy.
I was able to catch a vid (attached) of what the rear servo does from time to time / scary.

Do you think a bad servo of something else, if you think servo I will buy another one to test.

Mark Norris
ulrich 10 November 2025 12:1110.11.2025 12:11
I did a peek into the radio data of your last flights from the cloud. They look perfect, even with the former Antenna position there is no problem at all (i.e. Flight from 5.11.2025).
So your guess with the servo is very likely the problem.

so long ... Uli
http://www.vstabi.de
Eddi E. aus G. 11 November 2025 09:0311.11.2025 09:03
Hi,

I'd also lean onto the servo. Actually, do it :-) apply quite some pressure on the individual servos (swash plate above the link) and move the stick, does it get worse?
Is it different between the three?

—Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless