← VBar Control Classic

Buddy Box VBCe (V8) Master to VBCte (V7) Buddy on NEO

VBar Control › VBar Control Classic · Started by Jerry671 on 28 July 2025 03:2728.07.2025 03:27
Jerry671 28 July 2025 03:2728.07.2025 03:27
I tried Buddy Boxing using my VBCe on V8 firmware as Master on 2 Vbar controllers (VBCt and a VBCe) both on V7 firmware. The Heli FBL controller a NEO.

The issue, the Vbar controller kept intermittently switching from Master to Buddy numerous and consecutive times.

What’s the probability that Switch 1 is intermittent / bad without opening the radio and checking with an ohm meter OR it’s a bug in the V8 / V7 firmware.

The thought only crossed my mind after but I could have bind the VBCt and/or the VBCe V7 firmware as the Master to the heli (NEO) but I didn’t tried that method to rule out a firmware bug.

Your thoughts …
Eddi E. aus G. 28 July 2025 09:0428.07.2025 09:04
Hi,

V8 on VBar Control is actually not a firmware, but an App which only loads when a V8 VBar EVO VLink is connected.

So ... nothing new here, and even less when using a 6.x NEO.

The trick is anyways, both transmitters are transmitting to the model directly and simultaneously, no detour, and with the switch you decide which one the VBar on the model listens to.

To check if it's the switch, simply assign another switch temporarily. You can also check the secondary screen without a model connected, where you see the switch positions.

Usually, such things can happen if Master and Student are 'cuddling', standing closer together than like 1 m / 3 ft.
But you could also range-check the model, see if there's something off, try the same with another model, or try buddy boxing with reverse conditions, or with the two other transmitters only (if stick modes are the same, or with a skilled pilot playing the other role.

My thought, if it was a bug, we'd have heard of it already (and everybody else, too :-) ).

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Jerry671 28 July 2025 17:1728.07.2025 17:17
Hi Eddie,

Not mentioned, I had telemetry headspeed/Rpm assigned to switch 1/A. I reassigned telemetry to switch 1/B. Not dure if this was a conflict. I will try and duplicate the issue on the bench.

You did mentioned being too close, how does the Buddy box communicate? Does it transmit its RF (100mv) power to the other vbar controller?
Jerry671 28 July 2025 17:2128.07.2025 17:21
Hi Eddie,

Thanks for clarifying how Vbar works (using the required Apos not firmware) when my fleet of Helius consists of Neos and Evos AND my radios from the Classic, Touch, Evo and Evo+.

Not mentioned, I had telemetry headspeed/Rpm assigned to switch 1/A. I reassigned telemetry to switch 1/B. Not dure if this was a conflict. I will try and duplicate the issue on the bench.

You did mentioned being too close, how does the Buddy box communicate? Does it transmit its RF (100mv) power to the other vbar controller?
Eddi E. aus G. 29 July 2025 08:5929.07.2025 08:59
Hi Jerry,

Quote:me
The trick is anyways, both transmitters are transmitting to the model directly and simultaneously, no detour, and with the switch you decide which one the VBar on the model listens to.

There are two (synchronized) transmitters, but still, if they are very close to each other, the signal quality suffers. Radio 101.
Then, if the VBar 'feels' ambiguities, control falls back to the master, for safety reasons. Better again, buddy switch still in buddy position, back to buddy, and back, and forth.

A similar thing, even when we have near field mode, to reduce transmit power at (very) close range, to avoid over modulation, if a transmitter is very close to the model e.g. at power on, and if the antenna orientation is adverse, too, it may happen that the transmitter chimes 'disconnect' even though you still have control (another safety feature, the transmitter keeps transmitting no matter what, even if the user interface 'thinks' the connection is shaky because of a corrupted back link in this case).

Telemetry announcements shouldn't interfere, as shouldn't another common double, Buddy with Rescue.
They're (on the radio link) just bits, 0-1-2, and only change when the switch is flicked.

I'm not sure if you can replicate it on the bench, though, with reflections and everything indoors, it's very much different than outdoors.

Otherwise, you can mix any, for buddy boxing, there are no known incompatibilities.
Same as you could use any VBar Control to fly any VBar model (bind and fly, model sharing), the basic control functions plus motor switch plus bank switch always work (and when set up, also Rescue and Throttle Cut), even if you had different switch layouts for special functions.

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 07/29/2025 09:00AM by Eddi E. aus G..
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless