← VBar Control Classic

Evo V8.1.36

VBar Control › VBar Control Classic · Started by TRMRC on 23 June 2025 17:4823.06.2025 17:48
TRMRC 23 June 2025 17:4823.06.2025 17:48
If I am in the wrong fourm it is not quite clear enough where EVO issues should be. Sorry.

Mikado Evo V1 - FW. v8.1.36 All all servos moving in sync in a circle like motion. I isolated the Evo by removing the FBL mount setting on top a soft foam to completely isolate the FBL from the heli. The servo do not move the slightest or show symptoms. So my last thought is the chip is heavily distorted by the smallest vibration.
While the Evo is mounted and I input control the symptoms stop, when I sit in a hover the symptoms appear again.

Mounted to the heli, Vib log indicates everything under (50) everything seams really smooth.

This was driving me crazy, Never crashed, though it was the was the swashplate changed the bearing. Changed the main shaft. These parts were worn over a good year of use. All in all everything is perfect.

Has to be vibration related, but I cannot think of anything else to do ????

Video: https://youtu.be/1OFJCmbkkv4?si=86RKz2aW3UG0_T5E

Cannot attach video because the send box disappears while on phone



Edited 5 time(s). Last edit at 06/23/2025 05:54PM by TRMRC.
TRMRC 23 June 2025 18:2123.06.2025 18:21
Today I installed / swapped a New Evo I recently received for the IL 520, Servos do not move as shown in the video as pronounced. Not noticeable to the untrained eye. Still I can see the movement.
Although- I do have a Raw 420 also with a newly received Evo, V8 and if I pay very close attention I can also see all 3 servos moving in sync like a very slight circular motion with all 3 servos.

This original preorder Evo is very obvious in any heli as show in the video.



Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 06/23/2025 06:24PM by TRMRC.
Eddi E. aus G. 24 June 2025 09:1224.06.2025 09:12
Hi,

it's not quite clear to me: do you only notice that on the ground only, or also in flight (model becomes unquiet somehow when you leave the sticks alone)?

I'd be curious to see the readings (in a video, at best, model sitting still, then running on the ground, or in a hover) in Vibration Analysis Pro.
There, the noise levels picked up by the accelerometers are shown, and it would be a way to compare sensor packages.

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
TRMRC 24 June 2025 23:3824.06.2025 23:38
Hi Eddi,

A few weeks ago maybe even a month I started noticing increased vibration during spool-up, much more than normal. It feels similar to the typical initial shake when the blades find center during the first spool-up of the day, but this now happens every time I spool up, and it’s getting worse over time. There’s a noticeable shake until the blades “settle” into true alignment. Problem is this occurs every time I spool the heli up now.

At first, I thought it was normal wear and tear, but as the issue progressed, I began replacing parts: swashplate bearings, grip bearings, and the feathering shaft. These parts were all technically still functional, but had time on them basically worn out. I was going crazy trying to track it down, so I started doing more regular maintenance. Recently, I even swapped out the main shaft just to rule it out.

When I’m flying, the issue is most noticeable during spool-up. In the air, I hear a fluttering sound, but it’s manageable. The biggest issue, and the one that’s been driving me nuts for months, is the persistent elevator bobble sloppy feeling during a hover. I’ve been tuning endlessly and I’m at my wits’ end. In the video, I point out that the servos seem to be moving in a circular pattern something definitely off. And most likely the root cause of the low gain feeling and the bounce I cannot get rid of. Some what of a loose and sloppy head during hover. If you imagine a head shake and at times almost see it in the skids.

If I keep flying aggressively and constantly apply input, things seem okay. Same story if I push it hard the heli holds. But during stops, the performance falls apart. There’s a nasty bounce back on the elevator axis, like the gains are too low, while the aileron axis doesn’t seem to show much of an issue. This is the best I can describe what I’ve been dealing with. Now since I have observed this on the bench it is becoming quite apparent now, what is going on.

It may be hard to get a video of the issues and feeling but I could definitely get a video of each spool up. Comparison of the vibration log, Not sure what I can compare it to, but I could definitely produce the vibe log on this helicopter.
TRMRC 25 June 2025 02:0625.06.2025 02:06
Eddi,

I have some DOW SYLGARD™ 184 Silicone Elastomer. Electronics potting. Would you approve of using this to pot the MUI sensor ? I am receiving better results for #186 Shore 60 but I cannot get this.

Operating Temperature Range 45°C to +200°C
Dielectric Strength 500V/mil (~19kV/mm)
Volume Resistivity ~2.9×10¹·cm
Tensile Strength ~6.7MPa (980psi)
Thermal Conductivity 0.27W/m·K

Flexible (Shore A 43)
Absorbs thermal and mechanical stress, avoiding cracks or component stress


Optically clear, flame-resistant (UL 94 V?1/V?0), and electrically insulating.



Edited 4 time(s). Last edit at 06/25/2025 02:17AM by TRMRC.
Eddi E. aus G. 25 June 2025 09:5425.06.2025 09:54
Hi again,

say, you wrote EVO V1 ... what serial no. is it?

Because the original ones required casting the sensors into something, to make them deaf to certain frequencies in the 2 KHz range (even audible).
We suggested hot glue, because it's the simplest to come by, for everyone, everywhere, and it's simple to apply.
Silicone or resin are normally more fluid, require longer times to dry, and resin is for eternity.

Filling the whole thing with potting is probably overkill, and it's also a question of serviceability afterwards, same as with resin.

The point was, put an airtight blob on it, let the hot glue engulf the sensors all around—one thing many DIY's neglected :-/ even though the video for it shows it exactly that way. Then they went like, doesn't work either, and ranted against everything and everyone ^^

But such effects should not show on the ground, with the drive not running, and even back then, the effect was mainly a sudden tail kick, at high rpm, with high loads, when the sensors were close to being, or already, overloaded with noise: particularly the tail sensor did not just become mushy in response, but output a full rudder, randomly. Side note: NEO is different with this regard, here the tail 'just' became less precise, less locked in, with similar loads, which is also not optimal, but less dangerous.

Effects showing when the drive is running correlate somehow, either the mechanics are not balanced sufficiently, or not any more, worn, or the sensors are hypersensitive, or have become so over time. Since they are micro mechanics, they're quite obviously also subject to wear, and more so under obviously adverse conditions (like, on nitros, for example, but also if high-load high-frequency vibration tortures them for a long time, no matter which propulsion).

Next step: please let me know the serial no.

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
TRMRC 25 June 2025 18:4525.06.2025 18:45
Eddi,

Yes V1 Evo, As for the potting I have the skill and ability to only encase the sensor. This is not a problem. My question is there a problem with the specs of this potting to use to encapsulate the MUI ?

Hot glue in my opinion is lacking for better words garbage if I have access to to actual high grade potting material.

As for all of the issues you are mentioning Nope I am not seeing these symptoms. My issue is completely different on a whole other levell.

To clarify the Circular motion symptoms occurs systematically with all three servos and during spool up at the field, and during bench testing. I observe all 3 servos symptoms synchronously.

The symptoms do not happen just sitting there with out the drive not running.

As for wear and my machine status, I have changed everything, I explained in details the efforts put forth narrowing down the root cause. Just for reference my vib logs are below 50 on the bench vibration on the table below 40 hold the machine in my hand. During flight. I can also get the vibration result but I’ll be perfectly honest with you I’m not flying this Evo until I find a resolution for my issues.

I will report back with the serial number.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 06/25/2025 06:59PM by TRMRC.
Eddi E. aus G. 26 June 2025 09:4526.06.2025 09:45
Hi,

the technical side can only Uli assess, I'm sorry, and he's on vacation right now.
My educated guess would be, the processing temperature should do no harm, and if it's made for micro electronics, same.

Your video shows pretty clearly what's going on, and gotcha already the first time, the mechanics were revised.
When I'm explaining, I only try to cover as many bases as possible, so also a co-reader can follow :-)

//

Garbage, I hear you.
Problem with such words, in my personal opinion and from experience in support, is, too many co-reading on the net take what they read for the only truth and start worrying (which is OK) and pummeling (possibly without better understanding, possibly without even haven an EVO of that generation and with the ill effects on his particular helicopter), too, and the next one joins the brawl happily too, just because he can, anonymously behind a screen, and so on.
The expert who knows, who has access to the materials, and who can do it, can do it, in a professional way. Could even advise his fellows, like, while the hot glue if applied correctly may do the job, if you want to have it expertly done, do this or that, but mind that if you pot the whole thing, you'll never be able to even only replace an antenna or such.
The average pilot, and I don't mean to be contemptuous, can achieve a similar/sufficient result, with materials on board, and can fly safely, be happy with it.
This is not formula one or even space aeronautics, and even there, duct tape and WD40 are considered common tools.
But again, your average pilot, seemingly, cannot even wait for the glue to become liquid, let it flow, let it engulf/encase, even if following to oh-so-important videos (at some point, I fear people will no longer be able to go to the loo, without a youtube video ^^). Something we had to learn, too.

And then, if you read the original article carefully, there's also always the option to return such a unit, for a replacement—even today. Only the fourth option given is DIY, for those who do not want to, or can not, wait (read, your average hobbyist ^^), and (and!) feel comfortable with it.

You see, I've seen (also see attachments and compare with the video in the article) and heard (comments to the attachments: I have done it as you said but it does not work, garbage, BS) so many things in the past, and sometimes it's getting to me—nothing personal.
If what was suggested was carried out properly, all was well. If only half-heartedly, the result was ... nil.
For one it may be garbage, 'hell', craft glue on sophisticated electronics (or resin or silicone glue, or even potting, for that matter), for the other, it's a viable solution.

I wonder how layman 'pottery' would have turned out ^^

No harm meant! And sorry for rating, venting, getting carried away sometime :-)
We also were not happy in the least how this turned out, but on the other hand (and if there's no bad sensor on top), we analyzed and found the cause and offered a handful of solutions, and went looking for a different sensor which is not affected by those frequencies any more (instead of e.g. potting the original one forever), revised the hardware within a couple of months. And we offer to replace.

//

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.

TRMRC 27 June 2025 00:5627.06.2025 00:56
I hear you Eddi, poor choice of words. I deal with the same BS in the Industry I lead responding to the thousands of emails to people who don’t understand basic concept. Or trying to explain tolerances to a person who never seen a drawing or GD&T callouts as an example. It’s quite draining explaining things to people with a no need to know. Anyway I am just Mentally drained. It was the first word that came to mind….bad choice. My bad.

Let get back on track though. What would you suggest I do. Wait a week or so for ULi to respond. Go ahead and pot the sensor. anyway.? I didn’t know I could send it in for a replacement for the newer version was an option. I would like to do that just do not want to void any option to do so by using something other than hot glue.
Eddi E. aus G. 27 June 2025 09:1427.06.2025 09:14
Hi,

no worries, we're good! Same here, like groundhog day-year-life :-)

I'd recommend you return this unit to your dealer or to us, for a replacement (free, covered by warranty/goodwill, and with license transfer).
If dealer, let me know who, and I can help facilitate.

Easy way out, and for once it's a unit with the original sensor which could or could not be susceptible to the aforementioned, or become so earlier, eventually.

At best, start a service ticket at vstabi.info/devices, and we take it from there.

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
TRMRC 29 June 2025 19:1129.06.2025 19:11
Hi Eddii

Today I’m going to pull the Evo and replace with a Neo. Question, is there anyway to find the serial number without connecting to the computer ?

Also, I believe I received this EVO from ERCMarket so I’ll just send it back to you guys directly for me at that point is easiest.
TRMRC 29 June 2025 19:1329.06.2025 19:13
I got it serial number 27001032 THX

So, I switched out the Evo for a Neo, the symptoms are gone. Everything is solid. I will open a ticket soon as I have some free time and get the Evo ready to ship out.

Thank you for your diligence on this situation. I will pos the video of the Neo swap.

Edit: Ticket opened. Thank you!



Edited 4 time(s). Last edit at 06/29/2025 09:10PM by TRMRC.
TRMRC 30 June 2025 00:4530.06.2025 00:45
Neo swap:
https://youtu.be/hF_VLqxEqF4?si=ZSNMTHn-1OC26EEF
johnahamelv 30 June 2025 09:0330.06.2025 09:03
You are using the low profile Theta DH1 cyclic servos. I had issues running these servos with V2 EVO units, especially when programmed to 760us.
Eddi E. aus G. 30 June 2025 09:3230.06.2025 09:32
Hi Todd,

very good, thank you.

John, please elaborate 'issues', and if you like, in a post of your own.

In my opinion it's only useful (with this regard), if you experience(d) the same, the swash plate idly 'swashing', with the drive running, like in Todd's videos, no stick inputs.

Theta (and some other midi/low profile servos) might have an other effect (yet to be confirmed), where it seems that they seem to work sufficiently at lower refresh rates (like 166 or 200 Hz) but start causing troubles (wobbles, or the tail boom oscillating up/down) when run at the recommended/possible 333 Hz (where also 1,520 µs center pulse would be well sufficient, 760 µs has no real benefit here).

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
TRMRC 1 July 2025 17:4901.07.2025 17:49
Just To confirm, Theta setup is @ 1520-333 default settings programmed in the servos as well.
Thx Eddi. !
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless