← VBar NEO for external transmitters

During all flight the Motor Switch Off (Fail safe from lost signal?)

VBar › VBar NEO for external transmitters · Started by Adrenalyn on 4 May 2019 16:4104.05.2019 16:41
Adrenalyn 4 May 2019 16:4104.05.2019 16:41
Hi Guys,

Sorry but from same days, my V Bar Control Touch, With both my two VBar NEO, during the flight
without notice the engine stops.

i have the control othe all servo's and land in autorotation.

I' use every time External Governor.
rpm 2000-2200-2300
Hobbywing 200A


If i see the telemetry graphics Report i can observed the Hight RPM before cut of (i'm flyng from 200 to 2300 rpm and the RPM go out of the 2550-2600 during cut-off) But I don't hear an increase in turns by ear, I only see it later from the telemetry.


the problem smbra manifest as soon as I fly away over 50 meters but once it happened even at a constant distance for the whole flight of 20 meters
Could it be an interference problem? the signal on the ground looks good even up to 25 meters away from the helicopter.
The shutdown problem occurs on both models that fly with a 200A hobbywing. The problem started from one flight to another and now occurs with every flight

LOG Sample

04.05.2019 11:17:09;VStabi Start -- GoblinHITJ0
04.05.2019 11:17:10 Good;Reset Reason: Power On
04.05.2019 11:17:10 Good;Battery ID detected: 8018952D
04.05.2019 11:17:10 Good;Battery by Batt ID: HRB_8_12s6000
04.05.2019 11:17:10 Good;VStabi UI Sensor erkannt
04.05.2019 11:17:12 Info;Bank 2 Loaded
04.05.2019 11:17:12 Info;Bank 4 Loaded
04.05.2019 11:17:12 Good;Motorswitch Motor Off
04.05.2019 11:17:12 Good;Motorswitch Idle Bailout
04.05.2019 11:17:13 Info;Calibration Finished
04.05.2019 11:18:15 Info;Bank 1 Loaded
04.05.2019 11:18:19 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:18:19 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:18:20 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:18:20 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:18:20 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:18:21 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:18:23 Info;Bailout Start
04.05.2019 11:18:24 Info;Bailout End
04.05.2019 11:18:34 Info;Governor Active
04.05.2019 11:18:35 Good;Motorswitch Motor On
04.05.2019 11:18:37 Warn;Low RPM: 543 RPM
04.05.2019 11:18:42 Info;Raised Vibration Level
04.05.2019 11:18:44 Warn;Low RPM: 1316 RPM
04.05.2019 11:18:50 Warn;Low RPM: 1962 RPM
04.05.2019 11:18:51 Info;Governor Full Throttle
04.05.2019 11:18:52 Error;Extreme Vibration Level
04.05.2019 11:19:02 Error;Extreme Vibration Level
04.05.2019 11:19:12 Error;Extreme Vibration Level
04.05.2019 11:19:14 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:19:15 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:19:15 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:19:16 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:19:16 Warn;The Cyclic Ring is active
04.05.2019 11:19:22 Error;Extreme Vibration Level
04.05.2019 11:19:32 Error;Extreme Vibration Level
04.05.2019 11:19:34 Warn;High RPM: 2569 RPM
04.05.2019 11:19:35 Info;Bank 4 Loaded
04.05.2019 11:19:35 Info;Governor Stop
04.05.2019 11:19:36 Good;Motorswitch Motor Off
04.05.2019 11:19:43 Error;Extreme Vibration Level
04.05.2019 11:19:43 Error;Aileron Sensor Value out of Range
04.05.2019 11:19:44 Info;ESC - Umin:41.8V Imax:141.7A Temp:0°
04.05.2019 11:19:53 Error;Extreme Vibration Level
04.05.2019 11:20:03 Info;Bailout Start
04.05.2019 11:20:06 Info;Bailout End
04.05.2019 11:21:07;VBar Logfile End -- 04.05.2019 -- 11:21:07

Adrenalyn

Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/MKS Servo’s
Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/Kst
Servo‘s
Goblin Kraken Nitro/O.S. 105 HRZ/MRCI Muffler/MKS Servo’s

Mikado Vbar Control Touch/Vbar Neo Pro

Adrenalyn 4 May 2019 21:5204.05.2019 21:52
I noticed that since the problem occurs, during the flight there are the following warnings:
-Date Paket lost
-Fail safe

while in previous flights no anomaly was reported

Adrenalyn

Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/MKS Servo’s
Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/Kst
Servo‘s
Goblin Kraken Nitro/O.S. 105 HRZ/MRCI Muffler/MKS Servo’s

Mikado Vbar Control Touch/Vbar Neo Pro
Eddi E. aus G. 6 May 2019 09:4706.05.2019 09:47
Hi,

first, the antenna status looks OK, so no issues to be expected in general.
But if you get packet losses or fail safes (hold on the servos, motor off to the ESC), it seems like 'something' is interfering at greater distances.
You should be able to verify this with the motor running (but without blades), if you put distance between you and the model (at best, put the model on a non-metal stand (chair, table, bench ...), because right at the ground, the range is reduced significantly (a 'feature' of all 2.4 GHz systems).

There must not necessarily be a radio glitch, but it can also be an electric/EMV/ESD glitch, causing the sensitive electronics to hiccup.

In the graph, can we also see the input signal to the ESC? I would be curious if that remains stable or drops to zero, at the time we get the motor cut offs, and (by the timeline) in which relation.

Kind regards

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Adrenalyn 6 May 2019 19:4306.05.2019 19:43
Ok thanks,
Where i can see the signal of he esc?

I’m use only vbar sensor and take the rpm from the RPM exit of hobbywing esc 200A

Thanks

Adrenalyn

Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/MKS Servo’s
Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/Kst
Servo‘s
Goblin Kraken Nitro/O.S. 105 HRZ/MRCI Muffler/MKS Servo’s

Mikado Vbar Control Touch/Vbar Neo Pro
Eddi E. aus G. 7 May 2019 09:0407.05.2019 09:04
Hi,

OK, obviously we do not have the throttle opening in the log, I did check some of mine, in my cloud, with an ESC governed by the VBar and U/I sensor.

So this part will remain a mystery unless the ESC logs internally.

Kind regards

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Adrenalyn 7 May 2019 14:2107.05.2019 14:21
I currently use a Mikado sensor for both telemetry and battery. in telemetry it brings me back:
-voltage
-intensity
-absorption
-giri

as in the graphic I had attached before.
I will try to do the tests on the ground to see if the safe file enters and what to fly in another field to see if there is any interference related to the place I usually fly

Adrenalyn

Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/MKS Servo’s
Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/Kst
Servo‘s
Goblin Kraken Nitro/O.S. 105 HRZ/MRCI Muffler/MKS Servo’s

Mikado Vbar Control Touch/Vbar Neo Pro
Adrenalyn 11 May 2019 18:1811.05.2019 18:18
hello Eddi, we did various tests, without shovels but the problem persists. we re-tested away and see that:
- attached to the model: the signal is perfekt.
- 10 meters rises to 55Db
- 20 meters up to 61/63 DB
- 30 meters goes beyond 70DB
- 40 meters goes beyond 77DB


test
-in field free without canopy
- Model on wooden table at 1 meter height in free field

Adrenalyn

Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/MKS Servo’s
Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/Kst
Servo‘s
Goblin Kraken Nitro/O.S. 105 HRZ/MRCI Muffler/MKS Servo’s

Mikado Vbar Control Touch/Vbar Neo Pro



2 mal bearbeitet. Zuletzt am 11.05.2019 18:32 von Adrenalyn.

Eddi E. aus G. 13 May 2019 09:5613.05.2019 09:56
Hi Adrenalyn,

if the levels are above the threshold line at 10 m, all is well. This is a calibrated value for a range check.
It will drop at higher distances, but this is to be expected and OK, safe.

There are no entries for packet losses or fail safes in the log, which would cause the VBar to shut down the ESC, so the issue imo must be somewhere else.

Can you try a different ESC/motor combo on that model, or swap VBars, for a cross check, to narrow it down?
Please carefully check soldering connections and insulation, wiring and connectors, too.

Did the motor switch off in your tests? At this time, if you check the throttle opening bar on your radio's main screen, what does it show?
If you do a test on the ground, you can also connect a servo to the same output as the ESC, using a Y harness, so a buddy could check the servo position a the time the motor switches off. If the servo stays put and with force, the the signal output of the VBar must be presumed OK.

Kind regards

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Adrenalyn 15 May 2019 18:4015.05.2019 18:40
I did the tests on 2 different models with 2 different ECUs and the problem persists. I do not know what to do :-(

Unfortunately I don't have 2 different transmitters, it would be the last test I could do

Adrenalyn

Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/MKS Servo’s
Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/Kst
Servo‘s
Goblin Kraken Nitro/O.S. 105 HRZ/MRCI Muffler/MKS Servo’s

Mikado Vbar Control Touch/Vbar Neo Pro
Eddi E. aus G. 16 May 2019 08:5316.05.2019 08:53
Hi,

can you please post logs, of the latest tests?

The same with different models and VBar NEOs/ESCs etc. would point to the transmitter, but I can not yet see what should cause this, I mean if anything interferes it would be on the model(s), the radio is far enough away.

The only constant seems to be the Hobbywing ESCs (if it was both the 700s in your signature).

How's everything laid out, wired? Some pics might help.

Last, did you only test in one location (e.g. where you usually fly), and is there maybe anything nearby which could interfere, like radio masts for mobile phones or other purposes?

Kind regards

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
Adrenalyn 16 May 2019 11:5416.05.2019 11:54
Thanks Eddy,
Ok i try to fly in other location next week and post file log and show you a photos of my model. The esc are the same in my signature: same esce, same motor (xnova tareq 50xx 530kv).

Thanks for the moment, see next week

Adrenalyn

Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/MKS Servo’s
Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/Kst
Servo‘s
Goblin Kraken Nitro/O.S. 105 HRZ/MRCI Muffler/MKS Servo’s

Mikado Vbar Control Touch/Vbar Neo Pro
Adrenalyn 5 June 2019 21:3005.06.2019 21:30
Hi Eddy,
The Radio control and VBar are ok, the problem is on the autorotation... sometimes the autorotation takes hold while at other times it slips for a few moments and then resumes. on the ground during checks it seems to work perfectly, while in flight during maneuvers with much load it slips. I reassembled the old autorotations and now everything seems to work correctly. I can not believe...

SOLVED

Adrenalyn

Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/MKS Servo’s
Goblin Kraken/Xnova Tareq 550kv/Hobbywing 200ESC/Kst
Servo‘s
Goblin Kraken Nitro/O.S. 105 HRZ/MRCI Muffler/MKS Servo’s

Mikado Vbar Control Touch/Vbar Neo Pro
Eddi E. aus G. 6 June 2019 08:4606.06.2019 08:46
Hi,

thank you for tying up the loose ends. I wouldn't have imagined that ...

Best,

Eddi

Born to fly ...
forced to work.
VStabi VStabi Pioneer of Flybarless